Environmentalists Against War
Home | Say NO! To War | Action! | Information | Media Center | Who We Are

 

 

US Wants Nicaragua to Fall Because It Poses the Threat of a Good Example


August 6, 2018
Roger D. Harris / Mint Press & The Task Force on the Americas

The US has targeted Nicaragua for regime change. Some former supporters of the Sandinista party echo the US talking points: President Daniel Ortega's government has been, "in essence, neoliberal. Then it becomes authoritarian, repressive." But, in Noam Chomsky's words, Nicaragua has been targeted because it poses "the threat of a good example" to the US empire. Since Ortega's return election victory in 2006, Nicaragua had achieved remarkable success in health, education, and economic equality.

https://www.mintpressnews.com/us-wants-nicaragua-to-fall-as-it-poses-the-threat-of-a-good-example/246973/

US Wants Nicaragua to Fall Because
It Poses the 'Threat of a Good Example'

The US has targeted Nicaragua for regime change
because Daniel Ortega and his Sandinista party show
what truly progressive politics can accomplish

Roger D. Harris / Mint Press

(August 4, 2018) -- The US has targeted Nicaragua for regime change. Some former supporters of Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega and his Sandinista party echo the US talking points: Ortega's "entire government has been, in essence, neoliberal. Then it becomes authoritarian, repressive."

One would think that a neoliberal regime, especially if it were authoritarian and repressive, would be just the ticket to curry favor with Washington.

The Threat of a Good Example
In Noam Chomsky's words, Nicaragua poses a threat of a good example to the US empire. Since Ortega's return election victory in 2006, Nicaragua had achieved the following, according to NSCAG, despite being the second poorest country in the hemisphere:

* Second highest economic growth rates and most stable economy in Central America.

* Only country in the region producing 90% of the food it consumes.

* Poverty and extreme poverty halved; country with the greatest reduction of extreme poverty.

* Reaching the UN Millennium Development Goal of cutting malnutrition by half.

* Free basic healthcare and education.

* Illiteracy virtually eliminated, down from 36% in 2006.

* Average economic growth of 5.2% for the past 5 years (IMF and the World Bank).

* Safest country in Central America (UN Development Program) with one of the lowest crime rates in Latin America.

* Highest level of gender equality in the Americas (World Economic Forum Global Gender Gap Report 2017).

* Did not contribute to the migrant exodus to the US, unlike neighboring Honduras, El Salvador, and Guatemala.

* Unlike its neighbors kept out the drug cartels and pioneered community policing.

The World Bank, IMF, and EU countries have certified Nicaragua for its effective use of international loans and grants. Funds were spent for the purposes they were given, not siphoned off into corruption

Before April 18, Nicaragua was among the most peaceful and stable countries in the region. The otherwise inexplicable violence that has suddenly engulfed Nicaragua should be understood in the context of it being targeted by the US for regime change.

Nicaragua has provoked the ire of the US for the good things it's done, not the bad.

Besides being a "threat" of a good example, Nicaragua is in the anti-imperialist ALBA alliance with Venezuela, Bolivia, Cuba, and others. The attack on Nicaragua is part of a larger strategy by the US to tear apart regional alliances of resistance to the empire.

Nicaragua regularly votes against the US in international forums such as challenging retrograde US policies on climate change. An inter-ocean canal through Nicaragua is being considered, which would contend with the Panama Canal. Russia and China invest in Nicaragua, competing with US capital.

The NICA Act, passed by the US House of Representatives and now before the Senate, would initiate economic warfare designed to attack living conditions in Nicaragua through economic sanctions, as well as intensify US intelligence intervention. The ultimate purpose is to depose the democratically-elected Ortega government.

Meanwhile, USAID announced an additional $1.5 million "to support freedom and democracy in Nicaragua" through non-governmental organizations (NGOs) to overthrow the government and "make this truly a hemisphere of freedom." That is, freedom for the US empire.

Alternatives to Ortega Would Be Worse
Those on the left who also call for Ortega's removal need to accept responsibility for what comes after. Here the lesson of Libya is instructive, where the replacement of has resulted in a far worse situation for the Libyan people.

Any replacement of Ortega would be more, not less, neoliberal, oppressive, and authoritarian. When the Nicaraguan people, held hostage to the US-backed Contra war, first voted Ortega out of office in 1990, the incoming US-backed Violeta Chamorro government brought neoliberal structural adjustment and a moribund economy.

"Dictators don't win fair elections by growing margins," notes longtime solidarity activist Chuck Kaufman, citing Ortega's 2006 comeback win with a 38% plurality, followed in 2011 with 63%, and 72.5% in 2016. The Organization of American States officially accompanied and certified the votes.

The dissident Sandinistas who splintered off from the official party after the party's election defeat and formed the MRS (Sandinista Renovation Movement) are not a progressive alternative. They are now comfortably ensconced in US-funded NGOs, regularly making junkets to Washington to pay homage to the likes of Representative Iliana Ros-Lehtinen and Senator Marco Rubio to lobby in favor of the NICA Act. Nor do they represent a popular force, garnering less than 2% in national elections.

When the MRS left the Sandinista party, they took with them almost all those who were better educated, came from more privileged backgrounds, and who spoke English. These formerly left dissidents, now turned to the right in their hatred of Ortega, have many ties with North American activists, which explains some of the confusion today over Nicaragua.

Most Progressive Country in Central America
The world, not just Ortega, has changed since the 1980s when the Soviet Union and its allies served as a counter-vailing force to US bullying. What was possible then is not the same in today's more constrained international arena.

Nicaragua is the most progressive country in Central America with no close rival. There is a disconnect between urging Nicaraguans to replace Ortega with new elections and advocacy against US imperialist depredations. Unconstitutional elections in Nicaragua would further destabilize a profoundly destabilized situation. Given the unpopularity and disunity of the opposition and the unity and organizational strength of the Sandinistas, Ortega would likely win.

Most important, the key role of Northern American solidarity activists is to end US interference in Nicaragua so that the Nicaraguans can solve their own problems.

The rightwing violence since April in Nicaragua should be understood as a coup attempt. A significant portion of the Nicaraguan people have rallied around their elected government as seen in the massive demonstrations commemorating the Sandinista revolution on July 19.

For now, the rightwing tranques (blockades) have been dismantled and citizens can again freely circulate without being shaken down and threatened. In the aftermath, though, Nicaragua has suffered unacceptable human deaths, massive public property damage, and a wounded economy with the debilitating NICA Act threatening to pass the US Senate.

Roger Harris is on the board of the Task Force on the Americas, a 32-year-old anti-imperialist human rights organization. The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect MintPress News editorial policy.



What's Happening in Nicaragua
Statement in Support of Nicaragua / Task Force on the Americas [1]

(July 3, 2018) -- For more than a decade, Nicaragua was:
* The safest country in Latin America. [2] Its police force was internationally recognized for its innovative community policing policies. Unlike its neighbors El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala, where undocumented immigrants were fleeing to the US border, Nicaragua had kept gang violence and organized drug cartels in check.

* Far from a dictatorship. [3] President Daniel Ortega was democratically elected and then twice re-elected, each time with an increasing percentage and number of votes. In 2017, polls showed he had the highest approval rating of any chief of state in the entire hemisphere. [4]

* Where social indices were on the rise. [5] Literacy, small businesses promotion, free public education, poverty reduction, and economic growth were among the highest in the hemisphere. [6]

Then on April 18 things suddenly changed dramatically. Triggered by a minor adjustment to the social security program, which was designed to avoid austerity measures promoted by big business and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), violence broke out across Nicaragua. [7]

Incongruously, the opposition was led by students from private universities, who had little material interest in old age pensions, and by rightwing elements that favored draconian cuts in social welfare programs. [8] Despite the government rescinding the adjustment and its attempts to meet with the opposition and negotiate a settlement, [9] the violence has escalated with a death toll of over 200. [10]

Road blocks have been set up on vital streets and highways throughout the country. They are forcefully maintained by young militants, with reports that many are paid. [11] Organized crime, aligned with the violent protests, has infiltrated Nicaragua. [12] Some believe the extreme opposition is intent on escalating the conflict to paralyze or overthrow the elected government. [13]

This is within the larger context the US government targeting [14] independent and progressive governments for regime change. [15] Nicaragua is allied with Cuba, Venezuela, and Bolivia and has not served as a client state to the dictates of Washington.

The US has poured millions into Nicaraguan private non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in what is called "democracy promotion" but may be better understood as regime change training. [16] Even sources hostile to the Ortega government admit US involvement in the current unrest. [17] Meanwhile the US Senate is considering the NICA Act designed to cripple the Nicaraguan economy.

The Task Force on the Americas:
* Recognizes the Nicaraguan people may have legitimate grievances with their elected government. But the rightwing attack is on what the Sandinistas have done right, not what they've done wrong.

* Believes there is a huge amount of distortion and misinformation in how the situation is being portrayed.

* Supports an objective and independent investigation of who carried out and who provoked the violence [18] with all parties held responsible for their actions. [19]

* Commends efforts to mediate a peaceful settlement in Nicaragua, including dismantling the barricades and cessation of destruction of public property. [20]

* Opposes the NICA Act and US interference [21] in the internal affairs of Nicaragua including through the NED, [22] USAID, and other instruments of intervention.

NOTES and SOURCES
[1] The Task Force on the Americas is a 32-year-old anti-imperialist human rights organization. http://taskforceamericas.org/

[2] How Central America's poorest country became one of its safest. 01/28/12. https://www.economist.com/the-americas/2012/01/28/a-surprising-safe-haven

[3] Pérez, Foundations of Democracy, 06/25/18. http://www.redvolucion.net/2018/06/25/cimientos-de-la-democracia/

[4] Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega at 80% approval rate, 10/11/17. https://www.telesurtv.net/english/news/Nicaraguan-President-Daniel-Ortega-at-80-Aproval-Rating-Poll-20171019-0008.html

[5] Di Fabio, Economic growth in Nicaragua has helped reduce poverty, 04/18. https://borgenproject.org/economic-growth-in-nicaragua-helped-reduce-poverty/

[6] The World Bank on Nicaragua, 04/16/18. http://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nicaragua/overview

[7] The reform of the social security system and the interest groups of Nicaragua, 04/25/18. http://www.celag.org/la-reforma-del-sistema-seguridad-social-y-los-grupos-de-interes-en-nicaragua/

[8] Fernandez, A Nicaragua spring or an imperial spring cleaning. 05/07/18. https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/nicaraguan-spring-imperial-spring-cleaning-180507082508249.html

[9] Tricker, Update on Nicaragua: the national dialogue is back on…for now. 06/22/18. https://quixote.org/update-on-nicaragua-the-national-dialogue-is-back-on-for-now/

[10] Perry, After 2 months of unrest, Nicaragua is at a fateful crossroads, 06/22/18. https:/ /www.thenation.com/article/two-months-unrest-nicaragua-fateful-crossroad/

[11] Kovalik, The US, Nicaragua and the continuing counter-revolutionary war. 06/27/18. https://ahtribune.com/world/americas/2316-us-nicaragua.html

[12] Violencia armada en Nicaragua: un product importado (investigación), 06/24/18. http://misionverdad.com/trama-global/violencia-armada-y-paracriminal-exportada-a-nicaragua-investigacion

[13] Tortilla con Sal, Nicaragua's crisis – the latest stage in a permanent war, 06/17/18. https://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/Nicaraguas-Crisis—the-Latest-Stage-in-a-Permanent-War-20180617-0021.html

[14]Kovalik, The US & Nicaragua: a case study in historic amnesia and blindness. 06/15/18. https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/06/15/the-us-nicaragua-a-case-study-in-historical-amnesia-blindness/

[15] Chossudovsky, Social media and the destabilization of Cuba, 04/05/14. https://www.globalresearch.ca/social-media-and-the-destabilization-of-cuba-usaids-secret-cuban-twitter-intended-to-stir-unrest/5376720

[16] Blumenthal & Norton, US gov't regime change machine exacerbates Nicaragua's violent protests, 06/2/18. https://therealnews.com/stories/us-govt-regime-change-machine-fuels-nicaraguas-violent-right-wing-insurgency

[17] Waddell, Laying the groundwork for change: a closer look at the US role in Nicaragua's social unrest. 05/01/18. https://theglobalamericans.org/2018/05/laying-groundwork-change-closer-look-u-s-role-nicaraguas-social-unrest/

[18] Sweeney, Right-wing militias committing 'acts of terrorism' in an effort to destabilize Nicaragua, police say, 06/111/18. https://www.morningstaronline.co.uk/article/f-lead-nicaraguan-acts-terrorism

[19] Kaufman, Let's think about the consequences of our actions. 06/06/18. https://afgj.org/nicanotes-lets-think-about-the-consequences-of-our-actions

[20] Mejia, Open letter to Amnesty International on Nicaragua from a former Amnesty International Prison on Conscience. 06/15/18. https://www.counterpunch.org/2018/06/15/open-letter-to-amnesty-international-on-nicaragua-from-a-former-amnesty-international-prisoner-of-conscience/

[21] Blumenthal, US gov. meddling machine boasts of 'laying the groundwork for insurrection' in Nicaragua. 06/19/18. https://grayzoneproject.com/2018/06/19/ned-nicaragua-protests-us-government/

[22]Tricker, Manufacturing dissent: the N.E.D., opposition media and the political crisis in Nicaragua, 05/11/18. https://quixote.org/manufacturing-dissent-the-n-e-d-opposition-media-and-the-political-crisis-in-nicaragua/

Posted in accordance with Title 17, Section 107, for noncommercial, educational purposes.

back

 

 

Stay Connected
Sign up to receive our weekly updates. We promise not to sell, trade or give away your email address.
Email Address:
Full Name:
 

 

Search Environmentalists Against War website

 

Home | Say NO! To War | Action! | Information | Media Center | Who We Are